Whiteness and Orientalism in China

Problematic Privilege in the Chinese Context

© Matthew Skogstad-Stubbs

Apr 23, 2008
Orientalism: an age-old practice, ninglunbooks.com
Orientalism risks pervading Western business-men and -practices in China, creating a subtle racism that elevates Western mentalities above Chinese perspectives.

What some bloggers are calling "white fame" and some friends call "tall white man syndrome" is notorious, and quite nefarious, to Western activity in China. While the benefits they entail for Westerners are clear, the harm is much more subtle. Along with high-profile jobs, Westerns are led to believe that the hegemonic model of Western style business activity is inevitably preferable to Chinese forms of management, production and promotions.

Because whiteness, and the English language in particular, links certain Westerners to Western capital, they are in a position that is at once enviable, and dangerous. They are the conduits for multinationals that want a representative in China who can be the face, and often the right-hand, of their day-to-day operations. This means that China on the one hand provides high-profile jobs to Westerners that wouldn’t be able to get the same position in the West. But their position also places them into a group of individuals in similar socio-economic contexts that act as emissaries for the practice of workers’ and human rights violations, that mark Chinese factories.

As a result of their middle-management position, Westerners in China risk playing the role of quintessential Orientalist, most tellingly because Chinese who wish to profit from their connection to the West almost inevitably defer to them. The result is that they assume, somewhat naturally, that they deserve their position of privilege and power, and a subtle racism risks pervading their conception of the East. As a Western blogger living in China has written: “it can become progressively harder not to stereotype a Chinese stranger who stops me on the street as someone who will stereotype me, becoming a negative feedback loop of stereotyping and distrust.”

Most importantly, being defered to can almost necessarily lead to a belief in the superiority of one's own ideas and culture. This is a danger that is heavily linked to the practices of British, French and other colonizers. Because of their economic (and military) superiority, colonizers have almost inevitably believed in the superiority of their upbringing, and their perspectives.

There is a deep-seeded racism that is invariably linked to the age-old colonial mindset that Edward Said documented in his seminal work, Orientalism. It permeates practices like sex-tourism in Asian countries, placing the “Other” as an exotic creature ready to be taken. In many instances, the Western businessman views China as an exotic “Other” in this sense, plentiful and sensual, ready to be ravaged by the powerful (neo-)colonizer. The ability to take advantage of China, and believed to be deified for it, leads to a powerful Orientalism.


The copyright of the article Whiteness and Orientalism in China in China is owned by Matthew Skogstad-Stubbs. Permission to republish Whiteness and Orientalism in China in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.


Orientalism: an age-old practice, ninglunbooks.com
       


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo

Comments
Jun 10, 2008 8:04 AM
Wendy :
Indeed, Matthew, what you have described is not just a phenomenon in China, but also a phenomanon that is happenning in all of Asia and Southeast Asia as well as extending to third world countries too. The white colonialism is dominant for over centuries. In order to put an halt, some countries has adopted a nationalism policy that is in consistency to their economy and many glass ceiling position are reserved for national citizen. Racism issue has always been a field of human rights activists, as much as we would like to advocate a racial equality, what has been already ingrained to people's mind at grass root level is immenient. Capitalism which started a few centuries in Europe and UK has put their citizen in a highly complimentary standings too. As much as a description may be helpful, I would look forward to a constructive solution.

1 Comment: